First published

A £1,650 sale label on a £1,500 Game of Thrones book. Would the seller keep a profit?

Newly disclosed evidence

Not assessable

Outcome updated

Original source-time provenance, not forecast outcome

What we originally said
2026-11-18T02:14:00+08:00
What actually happened

Correction: the source dossier identifies 02:14 SGT on 18 November as its research cutoff, not a verified forecast issuance time. It records an issue date of 18 November, but the exact issuance time is not established. This Signal first appeared on the website at 13:31:40 SGT that day.

What we learned

A research cutoff, source issue date and website publication are different records. We retain the original forecast and do not substitute the later site publication for the unknown earlier issuance time.

What remains uncertain

No contemporaneous exact issuance receipt was found in the checked dossier or bounded mail search. This is not a forecast win, sale or verified return.

What we will check next

Recover a contemporaneous issuance receipt if available; separately compare dated like-condition completed sales and seller proceeds at the original checkpoints.

Supporting evidence
  • Original Signal and website publicationEvent · Checked Primary source · Public accessEvidence limits Separate source dossier labels 02:14 as research cutoff; exact earlier forecast issuance time is unverified.

Review overdue · no later published assessment recorded · Planned

Explore cases in OTR Learns · See the public outcome record

Explore this signal

Long Term at a glance

Short reader summary

The Folio Society priced its signed anniversary edition at £1,500. A month later, two auction-site listings marked sold showed £1,650. That sounds like a £150 gain, until you count selling fees and the cost of sending a large, fragile book. The buyer’s payment and the seller’s proceeds remain unknown.

Exact asset or item

The Folio Society: A Game of Thrones, 2026 signed and numbered 30th-anniversary limited edition

Asset type

Collectible

Reference price

1500

Currency code

GBP

Price observed at

2026-07-14T16:00:00+01:00

What this number represents

Tracking price

What remains unproven

£1,500 is the announced launch price, not a current available entry. £2,550 was a dealer ask, not a sale. No seller’s actual net return is known.

Exact asset or item

Exact asset or item

The Folio Society: A Game of Thrones, 2026 signed and numbered 30th-anniversary limited edition

Asset type

Collectible

Model

2026 30th-anniversary signed, numbered edition of A Game of Thrones

Edition

Limited to 1,000 numbered copies signed by George R. R. Martin

Condition

Verify number and signature, original clamshell box, rolled map, leather binding and condition

How to identify this exact asset

This is the 2026 numbered edition signed by George R. R. Martin, limited to 1,000. It includes the bespoke leather binding, clamshell box and rolled map. The standard illustrated Folio edition is a different product.

Price and what it means

Entry or reference price

1500

Currency code

GBP

Price observed at

2026-07-14T16:00:00+01:00

What this number represents

Tracking price

Price evidence status

Indicative

Price source

The Folio Society to publish the limited illustrated A Game of Thrones

Publisher: Lotusland Comics

Original language: English

Reading access: partial

Underlying origin: FOLIO-ANN

published date precision: day

retrieved date precision: day

Source publication date 2026-07-14

Source retrieval date 2026-11-18

Matching price source ID

B-PRICE

Purchase, sale and realised profit

No purchase or sale by OTR. None of the four marketplace pages independently verifies a cleared payment or the seller’s after-cost return.

The developments we connected

Separate development

  1. What changed

    Limited edition opens at £1,500

    Date of the development

    Evidence status

    Observed

    What the evidence shows

    The publisher scheduled 1,000 numbered, signed copies; original availability does not persist.

    Source IDs

    • B-PRICE
    • B-LEATHER
  2. What changed

    Launch sellout reported

    Date of the development

    Evidence status

    Observed

    What the evidence shows

    Trade coverage described the rush; this did not verify resale demand at a higher offer.

    Source IDs

    • B-SOLDOUT

Emerging insight

A limited print run fixes the original supply, not the number of future bidders. A collector who found a launch copy at £1,500 has a different break-even price from somebody paying a dealer’s higher ask.

How this exact asset could benefit

There is a financial premium only if a later buyer pays enough for a verified complete copy to cover its acquisition and all resale costs. The pleasure of owning and reading it need not depend on a future sale.

Who could benefit

  1. Who

    Owner of a complete signed and numbered copy

    How they could benefit

    A verified net resale above the owner’s total cost could benefit the seller; a listing is not a payout.

    Evidence status

    Still unproven

What we observed

Four exact-edition eBay records carried sold labels in August: £1,650 on 1 August; £1,995 on 6 August; £1,650 on 11 August; £1,880.69 on 30 August. Condition and seller net proceeds were not independently confirmed. These are four observations on one platform, not a rising market trend.

Four August sale labels, four different listings
Four August sale labels, four different listings
Date (2026)Price displayed
1 August£1,650
6 August£1,995
11 August£1,650
30 August£1,880.69
Seller settlement and equal condition not verified. £1,500 was the sold-out July launch price; the separate £2,550 dealer ask is not another sale.

What remains unproven

Individual seller settlements, actual buyer payments, nationwide turnover and repeatable profit at a current buyer’s cost were not verified.

What to check before acting

Entry conditions

The £1,500 publisher launch price applied at 4pm UK on 14 July 2026. At the 18 November 02:14 SGT research cutoff the publisher displayed out of stock. A dealer asked £2,550; neither a checkout at that price nor a sale was verified. Present executable entry unavailable.

Possible upside

Collectors could keep paying a premium for intact, authenticated copies years after the anniversary, leaving some sellers a gain after costs.

Possible downside

Readers can choose other editions. Even if listing prices remain high, a collector may wait a long time or lose money after shipping and fees.

Price or return range method

No probability, price target or appreciation rate is assigned. Compare like-for-like verified sales over time with actual acquisition, insurance, tax and selling costs.

Costs and fees

Suppose a buyer paid £1,500. At a hypothetical £1,650 sale, a 13% fee (£214.50), £35 insured postage and £15 packing leave £1,385.50: a £114.50 loss before tax and inbound shipping. At £1,995 the same assumptions leave a £185.65 gain. These assumed costs are not a fee quote or either seller’s receipts.

What two resale prices could leave after costs
View comparison values
What two resale prices could leave after costs
Illustration£1,650 resale£1,995 resale
Assumed 13% selling fee£214.50£259.35
Postage + packaging£50.00£50.00
Proceeds after selling costs£1,385.50£1,685.65
Gain or loss on original £1,500 cost−£114.50+£185.65
Teaching assumptions, before tax, FX and storage; not either seller’s actual costs or realized profits. The historic entry is unavailable at the publisher.

How hard it may be to sell

Four sold labels in a single month do not establish how quickly another intact copy can sell. Dealer inventory is not the same as demand.

Key risks

A damaged clamshell, missing map or questionable signature can undo a comparison. Platform disputes, costly international delivery, exchange rates and an absence of buyers can erase the apparent premium.

What an ordinary reader can do next

Check photographs of the numbered signature page, binding, box and map. Compare only complete copies of this edition. Before valuing one, record genuinely completed prices, condition, fees, insurance and the time it takes to find a buyer.

Original forecast record

Original forecast in full

The 2026 signed numbered A Game of Thrones book may keep a collectible premium if real long-term buyer demand outlasts its first resale wave; its documented August sold labels varied and did not independently show net seller profit at a current executable entry price.

Original forecast date and time

2026-11-18T02:14:00+08:00

Forecasts and review dates

6 months

Review date

2027-05-18

Original forecast

A collector premium may persist if genuine long-term demand outlasts the launch rush.

What to measure

Record at least three newly dated exact-edition sold labels with copy number, condition and delivery costs.

What must happen

Compare authenticated copies and distinguish price paid from net retained.

What would challenge the forecast

Only asks exist or comparable after-cost values weaken.

Current outcome

Not yet due

1 year

Review date

2027-11-18

Original forecast

A collector premium may persist if genuine long-term demand outlasts the launch rush.

What to measure

Compare 2027 sales frequency, like-for-like prices and availability of the standard edition.

What must happen

Compare authenticated copies and distinguish price paid from net retained.

What would challenge the forecast

More sellers appear but verified buyers and net gains do not.

Current outcome

Not yet due

2 years

Review date

2028-11-18

Original forecast

A collector premium may persist if genuine long-term demand outlasts the launch rush.

What to measure

Main failure test: seek multiple independent paid prices for intact numbered copies above full acquisition and selling costs.

What must happen

Compare authenticated copies and distinguish price paid from net retained.

What would challenge the forecast

If several verified resales fail to cover costs, the thesis is unsupported. No observations means unresolved.

Current outcome

Not yet due

3 years

Review date

2029-11-18

Original forecast

A collector premium may persist if genuine long-term demand outlasts the launch rush.

What to measure

Compare actual paid prices for the signed edition with the standard edition, adjusting for condition.

What must happen

Compare authenticated copies and distinguish price paid from net retained.

What would challenge the forecast

Most apparent evidence is listings and valuations, not sales.

Current outcome

Not yet due

4 years

Review date

2030-11-18

Original forecast

A collector premium may persist if genuine long-term demand outlasts the launch rush.

What to measure

Measure whether complete box and map command a repeatable premium after preservation costs.

What must happen

Compare authenticated copies and distinguish price paid from net retained.

What would challenge the forecast

Damage or missing material lowers returns or lengthens the sale.

Current outcome

Not yet due

5 years

Review date

2031-11-18

Original forecast

A collector premium may persist if genuine long-term demand outlasts the launch rush.

What to measure

Compare independently dated exact-edition sales and volunteered settlement records with the frozen claim.

What must happen

Compare authenticated copies and distinguish price paid from net retained.

What would challenge the forecast

No repeatable full-cost premium weakens the financial case; no evidence is not a hit.

Current outcome

Not yet due

How to test collector demand after the launch
  1. 18 May 2027At least three new sold records, with copy number, condition, fees and shipping.
  2. 18 Nov 2027Compare the frequency of like-for-like sales against the availability of standard copies.
  3. 18 Nov 2028Look for several independent verified sales covering actual acquisition and resale costs. Missing sales mean unresolved.
  4. 18 Nov 2029Check whether the signed edition still attracts a premium over the standard edition.
  5. 18 Nov 2030Compare intact boxes and maps, preservation costs and time to sell.
  6. 18 Nov 2031Test the original claim against verified sales and any voluntarily shared, after-cost seller statements.
OTR review dates, not sale forecasts. Only the signed and numbered edition of 1,000 qualifies.

Sources

Dated source

  1. Source ID

    B-PRICE

    What this source supports

    Reports £1,500 launch price from 4pm UK on July 14; announced price, not individual transaction.

  2. Source ID

    B-LEATHER

    What this source supports

    Publisher confirms bespoke leather process and July 14 4pm UK release; not secondary demand.

  3. Source ID

    B-MAKING

    What this source supports

    Binding, production and edition-specific materials.

  4. Source ID

    B-WEST

    What this source supports

    Contemporaneous announcement; July release timing was still prospective and news coverage overlapped.

  5. Source ID

    B-FORBES

    What this source supports

    Contributor interview supplies editorial context, not price evidence.

  6. Source ID

    B-SOLDOUT

    What this source supports

    Dated report on launch interest; a reseller publication with an interest in secondary prices, not seller settlements.

  7. Source ID

    B-COMM

    What this source supports

    Contemporaneous community calendar lists £1,500 at 15:00 UTC; an annotated schedule, not proof of a purchase.

Source limits

Publisher and launch reporting document the edition and announced price; they do not establish a resale premium. All four August results come from eBay. Marketplace links below document sold labels, not the dates those listings were first published, settlement, refunds or net proceeds. No synthetic price quotes were used.

Folio • original limited edition

Folio • standard edition, not comparable

AbeBooks • £2,550 asking, not purchase

Community • scalping concerns, not paid orders

House of Resell • specialist commentary

eBay • August 1, £1,650 sold label

eBay • August 6, £1,995 sold label

eBay • August 11, £1,650 sold label

eBay • August 30, £1,880.69 sold label

Back to Signals

AI powered research