Separate two different jobs.
First, a retrospective invoice audit checks completed shipments against the contract, agreed surcharges and actual service. It can identify a billing error or a contractually recoverable overcharge. A cheaper quotation obtained today does not prove that a past invoice was wrong or that money can be recovered. Confirm the claim procedure and time limits before promising recovery.
Second, prospective procurement compares written, executable quotations for a future shipment. Keep origin, destination, cargo, equipment, weight, cargo-ready week, service level, validity and payment terms the same. A later or less reliable service is not an equivalent alternative merely because its headline price is lower.
Use a documented baseline and calculate net customer savings after the full alternative cost, switching, extra handling, storage, demurrage, reliability and delay risk, and a pre-agreed review fee. Do not charge a savings percentage against hypothetical headline-rate differences or count the same saving twice.
This work suits an experienced freight operator, contract analyst or appropriately qualified specialist. Start with permission to inspect the necessary records and protect commercial information. Do not provide unlicensed customs or legal advice, submit customs declarations, change bookings or commit a customer to freight capacity without the required qualifications and specific authority. Refer specialist issues to a licensed professional.
Consider a hypothetical business reviewing 50 future shipments, finding US$300 per shipment of prospective customer savings after switching, service-quality, storage and other shipment costs, but before the pre-agreed review fee. That would represent US$15,000 before the service fee. It is not a claim for recovery against past invoices.
If a freight-review specialist receives 20% of realised and documented savings, revenue would be US$3,000 and the customer would retain US$12,000 of net savings after that fee. With US$1,000 of labour and other direct costs, modeled contribution would be US$2,000 before customer acquisition, overhead and tax.
This is a pricing test, not evidence that such savings are currently available.
For an appropriately qualified specialist, a safer route is to offer one small paid invoice review before hiring staff, buying software or committing to freight capacity.